What Religion Has Lost To Science, Part Two

Continuing last Monday’s Musing (http://inewp.com/?p=5268) here are six more areas in which our developing “hard” sciences replaced or marginalized religion in Western cultures (the first four have strong family resemblances):

7. Symbols and metaphors were replaced by scientific literalisms and facts. If scientists had nothing more exact than symbols and metaphors, they could never build a bridge, a rocket, or make reliable diagnoses and prescriptions.  An unfortunate but probably unavoidable side-effect of the scientific culture is that it has made us all much more literalistic, where an aphorism like “A fact is what you get when you stop thinking” could broaden and deepen our discussions and visions.

8. Beliefs became intellectual. Unfortunately, the stories that could connect our intellectual beliefs by weaving an adequate mythology haven’t yet evolved far enough. The stories of evolution, the 19th and 20th century myth of Progress, or the emerging stories of cosmology and Deep Time aren’t warming many hearts or helping many see life in more integrated and nuanced ways.

I’m reminded of the picture of Atlas holding up the world.  That image wasn’t created to answer the question “What’s holding up the world?”  It was meant to let us feel that this world in which we live, love, hope, achieve and die rests on “shoulders” not only strong, but also friendly.  Our modern sciences do the first part better than the second.

9. Wisdom was replaced by Knowledge. Or, more poetically, warm knowledge was replaced by cold, hard facts. Even in the Middle Ages, theologians knew the difference. They wrote often of the categorical distinction between sapientia and scientia.

“Sapientia” is the Latin word for wisdom, as in our self-flattering species name, homo sapiens. “Scientia” is the Latin word for knowledge. At its best, our sciences embody a spirit of inquiry helping us to strengthen the “shoulders” for future generations. At its worst — and what is understood by the majority of non-scientists — our “scientia” means millions more facts than any of us could ever understand.

10. God was replaced by Science as the authority on who we are and how we relate to the larger world around us. People have always ascribed human qualities to Yahweh, the God of the Bible. We say things like “God says,” “God tells us” or “God loves us,” as though God were a humanoid who could speak, know or love. But now, in our newspapers and on television, we hear people saying “Science says” and “Science tells us” — though, tellingly, never “Science loves us.”

There is no such thing as “Science” spelled with a capital “S.” In the same way, “God” isn’t the name of a Fellow.  Both Judaism and Islam are clear about this: Christians, less so. There are many sciences, and many scientists, as there are many religions and theologians. Scientists and theologians say things, and don’t always agree. But when we construct a sentence that begins with the words “God says” or “Science says,” we have created a humanoid fiction, an imaginary Atlas. 

11. The scientific method has largely replaced the “revelatory” method.  Some examples of people using this latter method include the Pope speaking ex cathedra, evangelical preachers claiming God has revealed something to them that is binding on others, the Mormon teaching that everyone can receive trustworthy revelations from God, and the funny but real bumper stickers that say, “The Bible says it, I believe it, and that settles it.” The scientific method – when it’s followed – doesn’t care who or what “said” it, only whether doubters can verify it for themselves through empirical, repeatable experiments. 

Alchemy symbols


Another way of putting this is to say that the “revelatory method” posits a kind of imaginary alpha figure (usually an alpha male), while the scientific method is more democratic and secular, at least within each science’s accepted paradigms and assumptions.

12. This leads to the last of these twelve ways in which religion lost much of its authority for growing numbers of people: The birth of agnosticism and apatheism.  It shows itself in the ironic coincidence of two historical events taking place in 1869-1870.

A.         The first was Vatican I.  We’ve heard of “Vatican II,” the liberalizing of the Catholic Church that took place from 1962-1965 under Pope John XXIII.  But we seldom hear anything about the first Vatican Council: Vatican I.  It occurred from 1869-1870, when Pope Pius IX declared that if a Pope ever spoke ex cathedra, as he was doing, then his pronouncements were binding matters of faith for Catholics. It would be risky for a Pope to try this however, since if time showed their pronouncement to be wrong or foolish, the pretense of papal infallibility would be over.

The only Pope since 1870 who has spoken ex cathedra was Pope Pius XII who, in 1950, proclaimed the physical, bodily “assumption” of Jesus’ mother Mary up into Heaven.  Joseph Campbell, the historian of world religious myths, pointed out that the bodily assumption of anyone was only coherent in the scientific picture of the world before Copernicus and Galileo shattered the ancient “three-story universe.” As Campbell put it, even if we assume that both Jesus and Mary “rose” up to heaven, and granted that they may have traveled at the speed of light, by now — 2,000 years later — they would be only 1/13th of the way to the center of our Milky Way galaxy. 

And what, he asked, would they do when they got there?

B.         The second thing going on in 1869-1870 was Thomas Henry Huxley’s coining (1869) then publishing (1870) the new word “agnostic.”  Huxley’s new word was made up of Greek word parts, and expressed the new spirit of the times, as more and more people were becoming comfortable saying they didn’t accept the assertions of the churches, and just didn’t know whether or not there might be a God.  Unspoken, but far more destructive to traditional religion, was the fact that they also didn’t care.

In the 20th century, as I’ll explore next week, religion lost even more important functions, both to new sciences, and to developing elements in our secular culture.

  • science_religion02
About the Author

Davidson Loehr is a former musician, combat photographer and press officer in Vietnam, owner of a photography studio in Ann Arbor, and a carpenter. He holds a Ph.D. in methods of studying religion, theology, the philosophy of religion and the philosophy of science, with an additional focus on language philosophy (The University of Chicago). From 1986 to 2009, he served as a Unitarian minister. He is the author of one book, America, Fascism & God: Sermons from a Heretical Preacher, (Chelsea Green, 2005). Now retired from the ministry, he is building a platform to become involved in national discussions of religion, science and culture. His book in progress is The Rise of Secular Religion in America.

  • Anonymous

    "But when we construct a sentence that begins with the words “God says” or “Science says,” we have created a humanoid fiction, an imaginary Atlas."

    Uh, correction: "But when we construct a sentence that begins with the words "God says", we have created a humanoid fiction, an imaginary Atlas".

    • 361Touch

      You obviously didn't get the point

  • ReligionSucks

    Number 13 of what religion has lost to science: a place in a fitting modern, humane society.

    • I Agree

      Number 14: Power to persuade millions in committing heinous acts

      • RATSG

        #15: Credibility

  • Pingback: Tweets that mention What Religion Has Lost To Science, Part Two | iNewp.com -- Topsy.com

  • CForLove

    i admit that religion has had its part in monstrous events such as the Spanish Inquisition but thats the whole point! its religion, not god. we humans were born corrupted and obviously corruption = events such as the spanish inquisition but it is all our fault not god's

    • Incredulity

      -_- Lol..

  • Pingback: What assumptions have anthropologists sometimes made when studying religion? How valid are these assumptions? | anthropologies hop.com

  • http://firstname-3401.bloghi.com/2012/03/20/hampton-inn-coupons.html Filiberto Kjellman

    I’m extremely amusedby your interesting site Will definitely return to your blog again.
    God bless yahoo for pointing me here.

  • http://www.google.com Thomas

    Hi, my name is Thomas. I’m a student at a university. I am writing to know if you’re interested in trading backlinks. It would help me a lot as my website is a source of income for me. In return I can offer you a backlink from a home page on a domain with more than 1000 links pointing to it. Send me an email if you are interested: thomasj-1992@hotmail.com. Please forgive me if you receive this message multiple times. I will answer all emails within 24 hours. Regards, Thomas

  • http://www.biniu.fanaudi.pl/4991-serwis-Naprawa.komputerow.Bydgoszcz serwis komputerów Bydgoszcz

    Great post, I conceive website owners should larn a lot from this website its rattling user friendly. So much fantastic information on here :D .

  • http://www.hotels-booking.com/author/admin/ I recently found what I hoped for before you know it in the least. Quite unusual. Is likely to appreciate it for those who add forums or anything, website theme . a tones way for your customer to communicate. Nice task Thank you for the sensible critique.

    Hi there very cool website!! Guy .. Beautiful .. Amazing .. I will bookmark your site and take the feeds also?I’m satisfied to find a lot of useful information right here in the put up, we’d like develop extra techniques on this regard, thanks for sharing. . . . . .

  • http://www.first.wloskiejedzenie.pl/595-katalog-Serwis.komputerow.Bydgoszcz serwis komputerów Bydgoszcz

    I wanted to follow along and let you know how considerably I loved discovering this blog today. I might consider it a good honor to do things at my office and be able to utilize tips shared on your web page and also be a part of visitors’ comments like this. Should a position regarding guest publisher become on offer at your end, you should let me know.

  • http://attractionbodylanguage.com/feed/ Body language signals

    It’s perfect time to make a few plans for the future and it’s time to be happy. I have learn this submit and if I may I wish to counsel you some attention-grabbing things or tips. Maybe you could write next articles relating to this article. I wish to read even more issues about it!

  • http://www.samsung1080phdtv.net/ samsung 1080p hdtv

    Wonderful article! I wish I had your insight on this topic and could write as well as you. I hope many people get the opportunity to enjoy this great content. http://www.samsung1080phdtv.net/

  • http://www.thehelpbook.net the help book

    Hello there! I completely agree with what you wrote on the blog site. Preserve it properly, because blogs like this are unusual on the net too. A greeting!

  • http://topfunnyads.com top funny ads

    sthss5foibodfnfoupomjof, Online pharmacy school, IhFvavj.

  • http://www.ads24-7.com See Herskovic

    I’m only hoping for this type of activity. I are unable to get this several folks to comment on my blog site. What’s your solution? Possibly some beneficial Guidelines would aid me. Please look at webblog at: http://www.shinjukueikawa.com

  • http://www.theautocarblog.blogspot.co.uk/ Nootropics

    I view something genuinely interesting about your web site so I saved to my bookmarks .