The Standoff Between China & the Philippines Shows A Bigger Conflict

By now many know about the naval standoff between the Philippines and China. What started out as Philippine marines halting 12 illegal Chinese fishing vessels and promptly arresting the crews on board after discovering illegally caught fish from Philippines’ Scarborough Shoal immediately transformed into a broader dispute involving territory and politics.

 

A pair of Chinese ships soon arrived to the scene preventing a Philippine warship from arresting the Chinese fishing crews.

 

It has now been three whole days since and both sides have sent a couple of warships of their own to the site of dispute with seemingly no breakthrough in diplomacy.

 

According to Chinese authorities on the matter, the fishermen were apparently “harassed” by the Philippines. Then Chinese press officials stated that the Philippines had blocked the Chinese fishermen from seeking shelter in tumultuous weather.

 

This is of course, blatant lying but for China, which claims the nearby seas, it is necessary lying.

 

This new conflict between the Philippines and China actually shows an even bigger dispute between China and the rest of the ocean-hugging Asian countries. A conflict that cannot be solved with compromise for the time being due to numerous factors.

 

For the past couple of years now, China has been staking claim to numerous areas of water including certain spots suspected to be rich in oil and marine life in the South China Sea.

 

Of course, other countries including Brunei, Vietnam, the Philippines, Japan, South Korea and a few others are in complete disagreement with China when it comes to where the boundaries should be drawn.

 

What doesn’t help the territorial dispute is China’s constant harassment of naval vessels belonging to other sovereign nations and high profile cases of arrests of Chinese fishermen who were caught within the maritime borders of other countries.

 

In numerous cases, China was the instigator by actually preventing ships from fishing in what is supposed to be their respective countries’ waters and even preventing ships from hired companies carrying out their work in scouting out possible abundance of oil.

 

This dispute that has pitted China against its neighbors spans all the way from the Yellow Sea to the notorious Mekong River.

 

In recent months, countries fed up with China’s behavior exhibited more aggression towards the country to show a “we’ve had it” message.

 

Vietnam in particular actually held naval and artillery exercises very near disputed waters which shocked and then outraged the Chinese government.

 

Officials from Brunei, Malaysia and the Philippines are actually working to completely change the names of certain bodies of water such as “South China Sea” which could trivially weaken China’s claims.

 

Meanwhile, the growth or presence of nationalism and wariness towards China in many of these countries are backing moves against China which has been increasingly forcing the countries’ governments to stand their ground so as not to lose their own claims and the backing of their voters.

 

So it goes to show that even if the current diplomatic/territorial dispute between the Philippines & China is resolved peacefully, there will be many more disputes with varying degrees of severity in the very near future.

 

(Cover Photo: AFP/Getty Images)

About the Author

Linxy lives in Seoul, South Korea and covers most news circulating from Malaysia to the mountains of Tibet.

  • Truth

    Your article is obviously biased! Philippines is the obvious instigator by trying to arrest Chinese fishermen. Nothing would have happened if Philippines left the disputed water alone!

    • will

      China is a big liar! like you!

  • Mistriss

    The chinese fishermen were in Philippines waters and it was fully in the right of the Philippines to arrest the chinese who were illegaly fishing there

  • Truth

    From what I read, Chinese fishermen have been there since the 15th century if not earlier. Philippines didn't exist as a country back then and only started claiming since 1997. Noticed the name Scarborough does not even sound Asian!
    It sure seems like someone is trying to bully Chinese once again. China has been bullied by everyone since 18th century and now she can finally stand up and defend her territories. I would not be surprised if there is a new plan by Japan, Korea, India, Vietnam, Philippines and Australia with backing from the US to invade and split China once again.
    Just like the 17th century when China was raped and pillaged by France, Britain, Germany, Japan, Russia, Austria, Italy, US. To see this, all you have is visit all the famous world museums and see the stolen treasures being proudly displayed by the thug nations.

    • Lei

      So I'm guessing USA belongs to ancient Native Americans and that everything in China belongs to the Mongols of the Yuan dynasty or that the oceans belong to the marine dinosaurs?

      Puh-leez. And by the way, the People's Republic of China hasn't existed until the mid 1900's a lot like the Philippines, so..which "Chinese fishermen" have been a few kilometers away from the Philippines since the 1400's? And what does this have to do with European imperialism?

    • will

      You Mongoloid Chinese must use your brain to think (if you have one).
      Imagine the distance of Scarborough shoal from china compared to the distance from the Philippines.
      Are you going to say that the whole Philippines belongs to china? then go ahead, take over and grab the lands, Take first the Australia or Malaysia who will sure strike back and will beat you up!

      • Truth

        Distance has no relevance.
        Falkland is pretty far from England.
        New England was pretty far from England.
        Guam is pretty far from USA. Hawaii is not close either.
        Philippines is pretty far from Spain and look who owned Philippines.
        Philippines is pretty far from USA and look who owned Philippines.
        Philiphines is pretty close to China. Yet China has never and absolutely no intention of owning Philippines. She just want Philippines to stop squat sitting on her islands. A very common sense request from any neighbors!
        Philippines should try to be a good neighbor instead of constantly encroaching on its neighbors.

        • Joie

          You're making my blood boil…Could you please read the UNCLOS before making such claims. Scarborough shoal is definitely ours. China wouldn't even fight us in the international court because they know they don't have strong claims over those islands so they resort to bullying instead. What do you mean by being a good neighbor? By letting you bully us and make us give up our sovereignty over those islands?

  • Truth

    The international law governing new claimant rests on who named it, discovered it first and a continuous use of it.

    Them shoal were named on Chinese map since at least 1400's and Chinese fishermen have continuously used it before and after 1400's.

    At the end or WW2, the entire S. China Sea islands, atolls, shoals were returned back to China (Republic of China) by the US, Japan and French. Philippines claimed the discovery of the shoal in 1950's. So, who is trying to bully whom?

    Yes, Philippines was a loose entity with lots of tribes and languages just like the Americas. The Spaniards and Americans came under imperialism and introduced the concept of nation. This is very different from China where concept of nation or empire existed from the beginning of the human culture.

    Even the name Philippines is foreign, derived from that of King Philip II of Spain. I see Philippines is just trying to re-write history due to their lack of it and to take what is not theirs.

  • freedom

    @Truth Tibet & Sinkian has been in existence, as long as imperial china, communist china existed only in the last half of the 20th century and has illegally annexed Tibet & Sinkian, the illegal and irresponsible claim of communist china to the West Philippines Seas can never be over looked, it is time that communist china be REMOVED as a permanent member of the UN security council due to its illegal activities, irresponsible behavior in the West Philippine Seas and continued oppressive and illegal occupation of Tibet & Sinkian.

    • Truth

      Tibet and Sinkiang were part of Imperial China long before the birth of Karl Marx and definitely before Philippines were named after the Spanish King.

      People from the "Philippine" islands should think about a proper name for their island nation instead of honoring a conqueror of their ancestors. Perhaps Luzon!

  • will

    These Chinese were very boastful! A real bug ugly bully! What they are doing in our territory? that shoal is a part of Zambales, Philippines! We should send Brgy Tanod or the local police to apprehend them! Because if they will be pursued by our navy, these land of the pirates China will make protest and will say that their ship and vessels are civilian (even though these vessels fishing vessels and the two maritime vessels are the one harassing the Philippine navy ship! China is really a big damn shit! Pirate-minded people! Imagine, the distance between the mainland China to the Scarborough Shoal against the distance of the Philippines to that shoal! In the first place, all those damn Chinese maritime ships and fishing vessels should be apprehended be arrested and put them in the Zambales Jail!
    Chinese Ambassador Ma is a Big Liar! She alibi that the Chinese fishermen were just anchored on the shoal for shelter against the storm. But the fact is, there was no storm in the area during the past weeks. It was and it is a sunny day in the area! What she must do is to explain why there are Chinese Fishermen with protected endangered marine species such as corals, sharks, and giant clams aboard their fishing vessels. Those endangered marine species belong to the Philippines. China is looting the Philippines of their natural treasures!
    China calls us Filipinos Island Monkeys, but China should look at the mirror first and they will see a giant brainless worm! Mongoloid Morons!

  • will

    May I call on the attention of the Philippine government to watch carefully the Chinese movements. Philippine authorities must not leave the Scarborough shoal because if they do, these damn China will surely put a military garrison on the shoal. And they will just alibi that these are just for their fishermen. We should learned about their tactics when China removed Philippine markers and construct buildings on the Mischief reef, when questioned, they just alibi that it is just for their fishermen, but after a year it was fully developed into a fortress with numerous artillery guns. China is a really a great liar! Talk and take tactics!

  • will

    China is just obviously taking revenge because the Philippines leads the ASEAN in a united stand against the aggression of China!

  • http://aa2841745.com a2841745

    I’ve said that least 2841745 times. SCK was here